Formed as Atherstone FC, Atherstone Town folded in 1978. They were regular members of the Birmingham & District League (runners-up in 1956), West Midland (Regional) League and Southern League. A New Atherstone Town were formed in 2004 and joined the Midland Alliance.
+ From 1947/48 all matches were played at Atherstone unless stated.
* Results not known
Associated with both clubs
Chris Dangerfield, Ernie Hunt, Mike Kenning, George May, William Tuckley.