Rotherham United (a) 2008/09 FLC

Carling Cup (Second Round) Tuesday 26 August 2009 at Don Valley Stadium (Att 5,404)
Lost 4-3 on penalties after extra time.

Wolves (0) 0: Ikeme, Foley, Collins, Stearman, Gray (Elliott 79), Kightly, D.Edwards (D.F.Jones 100), Henry, D.P.Ward, S.Ward, Keogh (Iwelumo HT), subs Davies, D.Jones, Potter, Hennessey.
Rotherham United (0) 0: Warrington, Lynch, Sharps, Fenton, Nicholas, Cummins (Mills 116), D.Harrison, Hudson, Rhodes (Burchill 115), Broughton (Taylor 106), Reid, subs Cann, Tonge, Yates, Green.

Referee: Mr N. Swarbrick (Lancashire).
Booked: Broughton 26, Harrison 27.

Penalties: 1-0 Jones, 1-0 Mills (saved), 1-0 Foley (wide), 1-1 Harrison, 2-1 Iwelumo, 2-2 Hudson, 2-2 Elliott (saved), 2-3 Burchill, 3-3 Henry, 3-4 Reid.