Overall
| Bull.S.G | 306 |
| Richards.J | 194 |
| Hartill.W | 170 |
| Hancocks.J | 168 |
| Murray.J | 166 |
| Broadbent.P | 145 |
| Own goals | 135 |
| Wood.H | 126 |
| Westcott.D | 124 |
| Dougan.D | 123 |
| Swinbourne.R | 114 |
| Hibbitt.K | 114 |
| Wilshaw.D | 112 |
| Mullen.J | 112 |
| Phillipson.T | 111 |
| Mutch.A | 106 |
| Pye.J | 95 |
| Wooldridge.W | 88 |
| Wharton.T | 79 |
| Deeley.N | 75 |
| Beats.W | 74 |
| Hedley.G | 74 |
League
| Bull.S.G | 250 |
| Hartill.W | 162 |
| Hancocks.J | 158 |
| Murray.J | 155 |
| Richards.J | 144 |
| Broadbent.P | 127 |
| Own goals | 117 |
| Wood.H | 110 |
| Swinbourne.R | 107 |
| Westcott.D | 105 |
| Wilshaw.D | 105 |
| Phillipson.T | 104 |
| Mullen.J | 98 |
| Mutch.A | 96 |
| Dougan.D | 95 |
| Pye.J | 90 |
| Hibbitt.K | 89 |
| Wooldridge.W | 80 |
| Wharton.T | 69 |
| Beats.W | 68 |
| Deeley.N | 66 |
| Hedley.G | 65 |
FA Cup
| Richards.J | 24 |
| Brodie.D.G | 22 |
| Westcott.D | 19 |
| Wood.H | 16 |
| Own goals | 15 |
| Mullen.J | 14 |
| Wykes.D | 12 |
| Broadbent.P | 10 |
| McIlmoyle.H | 10 |
| Hibbitt.K | 10 |
| Hunter.T | 9 |
| Knight.T | 9 |
| Hedley.G | 9 |
| Smyth.S | 9 |
| Wharton.T | 9 |
| Griffiths.B | 8 |
| Wooldridge.W | 8 |
| Hartill.W | 8 |
| Galley.T | 8 |
| Hancocks.J | 8 |
League Cup
| Richards.J | 18 |
| Bull.S.G | 18 |
| Hibbitt.K | 12 |
| Dougan.D | 7 |
| Miller.K | 5 |
| McCalliog.J | 4 |
| Sunderland.A | 4 |
| Mutch.A | 4 |
| Goodman.D | 4 |
| Rae.A | 4 |
| Milijas.N | 4 |
| Farrington.J | 3 |
| Eves.M | 3 |
| Gray.A | 3 |
| Dennison.R | 3 |
| Birch.P | 3 |
| Ferguson.D | 3 |
| Osborn.S | 3 |
| Keane.R | 3 |
| Taylor.R | 3 |
| Ebanks.Blake.S | 3 |
| Own goals | 3 |
