| League | Overall | |
| 1888/89 | Harry Wood | Harry Wood |
| 1889/90 | David Wykes | Harry Wood |
| 1890/91 | Sammy Thomson & Harry Wood | Harry Wood |
| 1891/92 | Will Devey | Will Devey |
| 1892/93 | Harry Wood | Harry Wood |
| 1893/94 | Joe Butcher | Harry Wood |
| 1894/95 | Harry Wood | David Wykes |
| 1895/96 | Harry Wood | Harry Wood |
| 1896/97 | Billy Beats | Billy Beats |
| 1897/98 | Billy Beats, Jack Smith & Harry Wood | Billy Beats, Jack Smith & Harry Wood |
| 1898/99 | Jack Miller | Jack Miller |
| 1899/00 | George Harper | George Harper |
| 1900/01 | George Bowen, George Harper & Billy Woodbridge | George Harper |
| 1901/02 | Billy Woodbridge | Billy Woodbridge |
| 1902/03 | Adam Haywood | Adam Haywood & Jack Smith |
| 1903/04 | Billy Woodbridge | Billy Woodbridge |
| 1904/05 | Billy Woodbridge | Billy Woodbridge |
| 1905/06 | Billy Woodbridge | Billy Woodbridge |
| 1906/07 | John Roberts | John Roberts |
| 1907/08 | Jack Hedley | Jack Hedley |
| 1908/09 | Wally Radford | Wally Radford |
| 1909/10 | Billy Blunt | Billy Blunt |
| 1910/11 | Jack Needham | George Hedley & Jack Needham |
| 1911/12 | Billy Halligan | Billy Halligan |
| 1912/13 | Billy Halligan | Billy Halligan |
| 1913/14 | Sammy Brooks | Sammy Brooks |
| 1914/15 | Fred Curtis | Fred Curtis |
| 1915/16 | NA | NA |
| 1916/17 | NA | NA |
| 1917/18 | NA | NA |
| 1918/19 | NA | NA |
| 1919/20 | Dick Richards | Dick Richards |
| 1920/21 | George Edmonds | George Edmonds |
| 1921/22 | George Edmonds | George Edmonds |
| 1922/23 | George Edmonds | George Edmonds |
| 1923/24 | Harry Lees | Harry Lees |
| 1924/25 | Tom Phillipson | Tom Phillipson |
| 1925/26 | Tom Phillipson | Tom Phillipson |
| 1926/27 | Tom Phillipson | Tom Phillipson |
| 1927/28 | Wilf Chadwick | Wilf Chadwick |
| 1928/29 | Reg Weaver | Reg Weaver |
| 1929/30 | Billy Hartill | Billy Hartill |
| 1930/31 | Billy Hartill | Billy Hartill |
| 1931/32 | Billy Hartill | Billy Hartill |
| 1932/33 | Billy Hartill | Billy Hartill |
| 1933/34 | Billy Hartill & Charlie Phillips | Charlie Phillips |
| 1934/35 | Billy Hartill | Billy Hartill |
| 1935/36 | Billy Wrigglesworth | Billy Wrigglesworth |
| 1936/37 | James Clayton | James Clayton |
| 1937/38 | Dennis Westcott | Dennis Westcott |
| 1938/39 | Dennis Westcott | Dennis Westcott |
| 1939/40 | NA | Dennis Westcott |
| 1940/41 | NA | NA |
| 1941/42 | NA | Dennis Westcott |
| 1942/43 | NA | Dennis Westcott |
| 1943/44 | NA | Emilio Aldecoa |
| 1944/45 | NA | Emilio Aldecoa |
| 1945/46 | NA | Ray Chatham |
| 1946/47 | Dennis Westcott | Dennis Westcott |
| 1947/48 | Johnny Hancocks & Jesse Pye | Johnny Hancocks & Jesse Pye |
| 1948/49 | Jesse Pye | Sammy Smythe |
| 1949/50 | Jesse Pye | Jesse Pye |
| 1950/51 | Roy Swinbourne | Roy Swinbourne |
| 1951/52 | Jesse Pye | Jesse Pye |
| 1952/53 | Roy Swinbourne | Roy Swinbourne |
| 1953/54 | Johnny Hancocks & Dennis Wilshaw | Dennis Wilshaw |
| 1954/55 | Johnny Hancocks | Johnny Hancocks |
| 1955/56 | Johnny Hancocks | Johnny Hancocks |
| 1956/57 | Harry Hooper | Harry Hooper |
| 1957/58 | Jimmy Murray | Jimmy Murray |
| 1958/59 | Jimmy Murray | Peter Broadbent |
| 1959/60 | Jimmy Murray | Jimmy Murray |
| 1960/61 | Ted Farmer | Ted Farmer |
| 1961/62 | Jimmy Murray | Jimmy Murray |
| 1962/63 | Alan Hinton | Alan Hinton |
| 1963/64 | Ray Crawford | Ray Crawford |
| 1964/65 | Ray Crawford | Ray Crawford |
| 1965/66 | Peter Knowles | Peter Knowles |
| 1966/67 | Ernie Hunt | Ernie Hunt |
| 1967/68 | Derek Dougan | Derek Dougan |
| 1968/69 | Derek Dougan | Derek Dougan |
| 1969/70 | Hugh Curran | Hugh Curran |
| 1970/71 | Bobby Gould | Bobby Gould |
| 1971/72 | Derek Dougan | Derek Dougan |
| 1972/73 | John Richards | John Richards |
| 1973/74 | Derek Dougan | Derek Dougan |
| 1974/75 | Kenny Hibbitt | Kenny Hibbitt |
| 1975/76 | John Richards | John Richards |
| 1976/77 | Kenny Hibbitt | John Richards |
| 1977/78 | John Richards | John Richards |
| 1978/79 | John Richards | John Richards |
| 1979/80 | John Richards | John Richards |
| 1980/81 | John Richards | John Richards |
| 1981/82 | Mel Eves | Mel Eves |
| 1982/83 | Mel Eves | Mel Eves |
| 1983/84 | Wayne Clarke | Wayne Clarke |
| 1984/85 | Alan Ainsow, Mark Buckland & Alan Evans | Alan Ainsow & Alan Evans |
| 1985/86 | Andy King | Andy King |
| 1986/87 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1987/88 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1988/89 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1989/90 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1990/91 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1991/92 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1992/93 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1993/94 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1994/95 | Steve Bull | David Kelly |
| 1995/96 | Don Goodman | Don Goodman |
| 1996/97 | Steve Bull | Steve Bull |
| 1997/98 | Robbie Keane | Dougie Freedman |
| 1998/99 | Robbie Keane | Robbie Keane |
| 1999/00 | Ade Akinbiyi | Ade Akinbiyi |
| 2000/01 | Adam Proudlock | Adam Proudlock |
| 2001/02 | Dean Sturridge | Dean Sturridge |
| 2002/03 | Kenny Miller | Kenny Miller |
| 2003/04 | Henri Camara | Alex Rae |
| 2004/05 | Kenny Miller | Kenny Miller |
| 2005/06 | Carl Cort | Kenny Miller |
| 2006/07 | Jay Bothroyd | Seyi Olofinjana |
| 2007/08 | Sylvan Ebanks-Blake | Sylvan Ebanks-Blake |
| 2008/09 | Sylvan Ebanks-Blake | Sylvan Ebanks-Blake |
| 2009/10 | Kevin Doyle | Kevin Doyle |
| 2010/11 | Stephen Fletcher | Stephen Fletcher |
| 2011/12 | Stephen Fletcher | Stephen Fletcher |
| 2012/13 | Sylvan Ebanks-Blake | Sylvan Ebanks-Blake |
| 2013/14 | Nouha Dicko | Nouha Dicko, Leigh Griffiths & Bakary Sako |
| 2014/15 | Bakary Sako | Nouha Dicko & Bakary Sako |
| 2015/16 | Benik Afobe | Benik Afobe |
| 2016/17 | Helda Costa & Dave Edwards | Helda Costa |
| 2017/18 | Diogo Jota | Diogo Jota |
| 2018/19 | Raul Jimenez | Raul Jimenez |
| 2019/20 | Raul Jimenez | Raul Jimenez |
| 2020/21 | Pedro Neto & Ruben Neves | Pedro Neto & Ruben Neves |
| 2021/22 | Raul Jimenez | Raul Jimenez & Daniel Podence |
| 2022/23 | Ruben Neves & Daniel Podence | Ruben Neves & Daniel Podence |