FA Cup (Second Round) Saturday 31 January 1891 at Accrington Cricket Ground
After Extra Time

Accrington (1) 2 (Pendergast 40, Kirkham 50): Hay, McDermit, McLellan, Shuttleworth, Howarth, Tattershall, Wilkinson, Whitehead, Gallocher, Kirkham, Pendegast.
Wolves (1) 3 (Booth 19, Wood 85, Worrall 119): Rose, Baugh, C Mason, Fletcher, Allen, Davies, Wykes, Thomson, Worrall, Wood, Booth.

Referee: Mr W Stacey (Sheffield).
Order of Goals: W,a,a,W,W.