FA Cup (First Round Replay)- Thursday 21 January 1909 at Crystal Palace (Att 7,000)
After Extra Time, 2-2 at 90 minutes.

Crystal Palace (1) 4 (Lawrence 9, Garnett 68, Bauchop 104, Needham 118): Johnson, Collins, Collyer, Innerd, Ryan, Brearley, Garnett, Lawrence, Bauchop, Woodger, Needham.
Wolves (1) 2 (Hedley 1, Radford 83): Lunn, Jones, Collins, Shelton, Hunt, Bishop, Harrison, Blunt, Hedley, Radford, Pedley.

Referee: Mr S Peers (Liverpool).
Injuries: Several players were knocked out by the heavy sodden ball. All were able to continue after being treated by the trainers.
Order of Goals: W,c,c,W,c,c.