Monday 8 April 1895 at Goodison Park (Att 10,000)

Everton (1) 2 (Milward*, Bell*): Hillman, Kelso, Parry, Boyle, Holt, Stewart, Latta, Bell, Geary, Chadwick, Milward.
Wolves (1) 1 (Wykes*): Hassall, Baugh, Dunn, Nurse, Malpass, Fleming, Wykes, Black, Edge, Bell, Griffin.

Order of Goals: W,e,e.
Re-Arranged: Wolves trip to Liverpool had originally been postponed.
Position: 11th.