1890 (a) Accrington S (1) Football League L 3-6
1891 (a) Accrington S (1) Football League W 2-1
1894 (a) Ardwick Friendly W 2-1
1895 (H) Sunderland Football League L 1-4
1900 (a) Sunderland Football League W 2-1
1901 (a) The Wednesday Football League L 0-2
1903 (a) Blackburn Rovers Football League L 0-1
1904 (a) The Wednesday Football League L 0-4
1908 (a) Stockport County Football League W 3-1
1914 (a) Blackpool Football League L 0-2
1921 (H) Hull City Football League L 1-3
1925 (a) Stockport County Football League D 1-1
1927 (H) Walsall Friendly L 1-2
1930 (a) Charlton Athletic Football League L 0-2
1938 (a) Manchester City Football League W 4-2
1944 (a) Stoke City War Competition L 3-9
1948 (a) Middlesbrough Football League W 4-2
1949 (H) Bolton Wanderers Football League W 2-0
1952 (a) Sunderland Football League D 1-1
1955 (H) Portsmouth Football League D 2-2
1957 (a) Sunderland Football League W 3-2
1966 (H) Leyton Orient Football League W 2-1
1972 (H) Newcastle United Football League W 2-0
1974 (H) Southampton Football League W 2-1
1977 (a) Millwall Football League D 1-1
1983 (a) Fulham Football League W 3-1
1985 (H) Carlisle United Football League L 0-2
1986 (H) Chesterfield Football League W 1-0
1987 (H) Peterborough United Football League L 0-3
1988 (H) Hereford United Football League W 2-0
1990 (a) Newcastle United Football League W 4-1
1991 (H) Watford Football League D 0-0
1992 (a) Grimsby Town Football League W 2-0
1994 (a) Peterborough United Football League W 1-0
2001 (a) Burnley Football League W 2-1
2003 (H) Derby County Football League D 1-1
2005 (H) Plymouth Argyle Football League D 1-1
2008 (H) Sheffield United Football League D 0-0
2011 (a) West Ham United Premier League L 0-2
2013 (a) Crystal Palace Football League L 1-3
2014 (a) Tranmere Rovers Football League D 1-1
2016 (a) Brighton & Hove Albion Football League W 1-0
2020 (a) Watford Premier League L 1-2