Birmingham Cup (Second Round) Monday 25 February 1895 at Coventry Road (Att 2,000)

Small Heath (1) 3 (Hallam 4, Mobley*, Wheldon*): Watson, Purves, Oliver, Ollis, Jenkins, E Devey, Hallam, Walton, Mobley, Wheldon, Hands.
Wolves (1) 3 (Wykes*, Wykes*, Fleming*): Halsall, Baugh, Dunn, Nurse, Haynes, Crump, Wykes, Black, Bell, Fleming, Tonks.

Order of Goals: s,W,s,W,s,W.
Note: Wolves refused to play extra time and consequently the Birmingham FA ordered the replay to take place back at Small Heath. This after a Small Heath protest claiming the win after Wolves refusal to play the extra time.
Bye: Wolves had received a bye in the first round.
Re-Arranged: Originally scheduled for 9 February.