FA Cup (First Round Replay)- Wednesday 24 January 1912 at Molineux Att 8,751)

Wolves (7) 10 (Needham 3 17, Brooks 15 19, Harrison 22 32, Young 26p, Hedley 53, Halligan 70 85): Boxley, Collins, Garratly, Groves, Young, Bishop, Harrison, Hedley, Halligan, Needham, Brooks.
Watford (0) 0: Webster, Smith, Stewart, C Bulling, Grimsdell, Blythe, Tattersall, Gregory, Dunn, White, Squires.

Referee: Mr I Baker (Nantwich).
Penalty: Awarded for handball against Harry Bulling.
Rearranged: This replay had been postponed twice, because of snow and fog.
Newspaper: Some reports suggest Billy Halligan netted a hat-trick and Billy Harrison just one.