| A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z |
| From | Cost | Date | To | Cost | Date | ||
| Smart | B | Hednesford Town | Fee Unknown | 27 September 1912 | Bloxwich Strollers | Fee Unknown | 28 March 1905 |
| Smart | F L | Redditch | Fee Unknown | 12 May 1921 | Aston Villa | Fee Unknown | 1 November 1921 |
| Smart | H H | Aston Villa | Fee Unknown | 5 December 1919 | Unknown | 3 April 1905 | |
| Smart | L | Folkestone Town | Fee Unknown | 10 October 1938 | Port Vale | Fee Unknown | 4 March 1939 |
| Smith | A E | Amateur | NP | 13 May 1939 | Released | 29 October 1943 | |
| Smith | A J | WBA | Fee Unknown | 5 May 1931 | Bristol Rovers | Fee Unknown | 30 April 1934 |
| Chelsea | Guest | 1941-42 | |||||
| Chelsea | Guest | 1944-45 | |||||
| Smith | D | Burton Albion | Fee Unknown | 12 September 1990 | Released | 14 June 1905 | |
| Smith | E | Bilston United | Fee Unknown | 1 September 1903 | Dudley Town | Fee Unknown | 1 May 1905 |
| Smith | G | Newport County | Fee Unknown | 17 April 1905 | Bournemouth & BA | Fee Unknown | 19 September 1934 |
| Smith | G M | Tottenham Hotspur | Free | 31 August 1982 | South Africa | Released | 1984 |
| Smith | H | Amateur | NP | 1951 | Kidderminster Harriers | Fee Unknown | 14 July 1954 |
| Smith | J | Springfield RS | Fee Unknown | 15 April 1896 | Dudley Town | Fee Unknown | 13 March 1905 |
| Stafford Rangers | Fee Unknown | 1 September 1902 | Birmingham City | Fee Unknown | 20 April 1906 | ||
| Smith | J | Juniors | NA | 21 July 2023 | Frickley Athletic | Loan | 7 October 2020 |
| Kettering Town | Loan | 14 August 2021 | |||||
| Walsall | Loan | 27 January 2023 | |||||
| Walsall | Fee Unknown | 21 July 2023 | |||||
| Smith | J J A | Juniors | NA | 7 June 1993 | Crystal Palace | £1,000,000 | 21 October 1997 |
| Smith | L J | Juniors | NA | 27 April 1945 | Aston Villa | Fee Unknown | 2 February 1956 |
| Smith | M | Sutton Coldfield T | Non Contract | 23 October 1987 | Stourbridge | Free | cs1988 |
| Contracted | NA | 6 January 1987 | |||||
| Smith | R | Colchester United | Fee Unknown | 26 October 1937 | Tranmere Rovers | Fee Unknown | 4 June 1938 |
| Smith | R F | Juniors | Non Contract | 1984 | Moor Green | Released | 1985 |
| Smith | W | Willenhall | Fee Unknown | 3 May 1894 | Portsmouth | Fee Unknown | Nov 1898 |
| Smith | W C | Denaby United | Fee Unknown | 8 May 1931 | Southend United | Fee Unknown | 1 August 1933 |
| Smout | J T | Unknown | Fee Unknown | 10 April 1893 | Stafford Rangers | Fee Unknown | 20 September 1895 |
| Smyth | S | Dundella [NIre] | Fee Unknown | 23 July 1947 | Stoke City | £20,000 | 28 August 1951 |
| Solly | L A | Juniors | NA | 1 August 2000 | Bury | Released | 1 October 2003 |
| Somerfield | A G | Mansfield Town | Fee Unknown | 17 March 1939 | Mansfield Town | Guest | 1941-42 |
| Millwall | Guest | 1943-44 | |||||
| Clapton Orient | Guest | 1944-45 | |||||
| QPR | Guest | 1944-45 | |||||
| QPR | Guest | 1945-46 | |||||
| Wrexham | Fee Unknown | 1 June 1947 | |||||
| Sondergaard | A | Odense [Den] | Free | 26 January 2018 | Randers [Den] | Loan | 31 August 2021 |
| Hereford | Loan | 31 January 2022 | |||||
| Swansea City | Released | 31 January 2023 | |||||
| Sowerby | W H R | Pilkington Rec | Fee Unknown | 15 May 1950 | Grimsby Town | Fee Unknown | 9 January 1954 |
| Spelman | M T | Whitley Bay | Fee Unknown | 6 November 1969 | Watford | Fee Unknown | 9 August 1971 |
| Spencer | A R | Port Vale | Fee Unknown | 5 June 1923 | Port Vale | Fee Unknown | 29 November 1923 |
| Spiers | C H | Tottenham Hotspur | Fee Unknown | 6 July 1933 | Retired | NA | 18 April 1905 |
| Spray | J M K T | Juniors | NA | 1 August 2009 | Accrington Stanley (2) | Loan | 4 October 2011 |
| Springthorpe | T A | Juniors | NA | 6 December 1940 | Coventry City | Substantial | 21 December 1950 |
| Stack | G C | Reading | Loan | 9 August 2007 | NA | ||
| Plymouth Argyle | Loan | 26 March 2009 | |||||
| Stainsby | J | Amateur | NP | 2 October 1949 | Barnsley | Fee Unknown | 1 December 1950 |
| Stancliffe | P I | Sheffield United | Loan | 8 November 1990 | York City | Free | 8 July 1991 |
| Sheffield United | Free | 17 December 1990 | |||||
| Stanford | S | 1880 | 1885 | ||||
| Stanley | J | Crewe Alexandra | Fee Unknown | 23 February 1905 | Bolton Wanderers | Fee Unknown | 24 April 1906 |
| Stearman | R J M | Leicester City | £1,000,000 | 25 June 2008 | Ipswich Town | Loan | 29 January 2013 |
| Fulham | Loan | 31 August 2016 | Fulham | £2,000,000 | 1 September 2015 | ||
| Steele | T W | Shrewsbury Town | £80,000 | 22 February 1989 | Stoke City | Loan | 20 February 1992 |
| Bradford City | Fee Unknown | 16 July 1993 |
|
