| First Team | Second Team Matches | League debuts | Associated with both clubs | Transfers |
| 256 | Hargreaves, H | Molineux | 19 November 1921 | L 0-1 | |
| 550 | Burnside, D | Molineux | 7 September 1966 | D 1-1 | 1g |
| 587 | Powell, B | Selhurst Park | 10 March 1972 | D 1-1 | Sub |
| 619 | Villazan, R | Molineux | 30 August 1980 | W 2-1 | |
| 634 | Dodd, A | Selhurst Park | 27 November 1982 | W 4-3 | |
| 666 | Biggins, S | Selhurst Park | 9 March 1985 | D 0-0 | |
| 750 | Ferguson, D | Molineux | 15 January 1994 | W 2-0 | |
| 751 | Marsden, C | Molineux | 15 January 1994 | W 2-0 | |
| 810 | Taylor, S | Selhurst Park | 28 September 1999 | L 0-1 | |
| 889 | McIndoe, M | Molineux | 28 November 2006 | D 1-1 | Sub |
| 906 | Ebanks, S | Selhurst Park | 12 January 2008 | L 0-3 | |
| 914 | Shackell, J | Molineux | 16 September 2008 | W 2-1 | Sub |
