| History | Player Breakdown | List |
| Date | Player | Opponents | Competition | Results | Seasons | |
| 20 October 1883 | Brodie, Jack (4) | St John United (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 9-1 | 1883/84 |
| 10 November 1883 | Brodie, Jack | St Pauls (H) | Wrekin Cup | W | 7-0 | 1883/84 |
| 17 November 1883 | Brodie, Jack | Shrewsbury Castle Blues (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 10-0 | 1883/84 |
| 8 December 1883 | Brodie, Jack | Stafford Rangers (H) | Walsall Senior Cup | W | 3-0 | 1883/84 |
| 24 December 1883 | Brodie, Jack (10) | Villa Cross (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 15-0 | 1883/84 |
| 31 May 1884 | Brodie, Jack (6) | Hadley (N) | Wrekin Cup | W | 11-0 | 1883/84 |
| 31 May 1884 | Lowder, Lowder | Hadley (N) | Wrekin Cup | W | 11-0 | 1883/84 |
| 20 September 1884 | Brodie, Jack (10) | Brownhills (H) | Walsall Senior Cup | W | 20-0 | 1884/85 |
| 18 October 1884 | Stanford, Sid (4) | St Thomas (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 11-1 | 1884/85 |
| 1 November 1884 | Stanford, Sid (5) | Stourbridge Standard (H) | Staffordshire Senior Cup | W | 5-1 | 1884/85 |
| 29 November 1884 | Brodie, Jack (6) | Handsworth Groves (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 12-0 | 1884/85 |
| 3 January 1885 | Brodie, Jack | Birmingham Excelsior (H) | Walsall Senior Cup | W | 4-0 | 1884/85 |
| 7 February 1885 | Brazier, Gilbert | Hanley (H) | Staffordshire Senior Cup | W | 4-0 | 1884/85 |
| 5 December 1885 | Aston, Harry | Aston Unity (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 7-1 | 1885/86 |
| 13 November 1886 | Hunter, Tom (4) | Crosswells Brewery (H) | FA Cup | W | 14-0 | 1886/87 |
| 13 November 1886 | Brodie, Jack | Crosswells Brewery (H) | FA Cup | W | 14-0 | 1886/87 |
| 13 November 1886 | Knight, Ton | Crosswells Brewery (H) | FA Cup | W | 14-0 | 1886/87 |
| 11 December 1886 | Horton, Ton | Cannock (H) | Staffordshire Senior Cup | W | 6-0 | 1886/87 |
| 3 November 1888 | Wood, Harry | Derby County (H) | Football League | W | 4-1 | 1888/89 |
| 24 December 1888 | Brodie, Jack | Shrewsbury Town (a) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 10-0 | 1888/89 |
| 16 February 1889 | Knight, Tom | Walsall Town Swifts (H) | FA Cup | W | 6-1 | 1888/89 |
| 22 February 1890 | Brodie, Jack (5) | Stoke (H) | FA Cup | W | 8-0 | 1889/90 |
| 15 March 1890 | Wykes, David | Bolton Wanderers (H) | Football League | W | 5-1 | 1889/90 |
| 19 January 1891 | Wood, Harry | Walsall Town Swifts (H) | Staffordshire Senior Cup | W | 5-1 | 1890/91 |
| 28 November 1891 | Topham, Dick | Blackburn Rovers (H) | Football League | W | 6-1 | 1891/92 |
| 18 April 1892 | Wood, Harry | Aston Villa (a) | Football League | W | 6-3 | 1891/92 |
| 19 November 1892 | Butcher, Joe (5) | Accrington (H) | Division One | W | 5-3 | 1892/93 |
| 5 April 1893 | Wood, Harry (5) | Hednesford (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 12-1 | 1892/93 |
| 5 April 1893 | Griffin, Alf | Hednesford (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 12-1 | 1892/93 |
| 25 November 1893 | Butcher, Joe (4) | Stoke (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-2 | 1893/94 |
| 11 January 1897 | Smith, Bill | West Bromwich Albion (H) | Staffordshire Senior Cup | W | 5-1 | 1895/96 |
| 6 February 1897 | Beats, Billy (4) | Small Heath (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 8-2 | 1896/97 |
| 19 December 1898 | Miller, Jack (4) | Loughborough (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 11-0 | 1898/99 |
| 19 December 1898 | Blackett, Joe | Loughborough (H) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 11-0 | 1898/99 |
| 24 December 1898 | Blackett, Joe | Sheffield United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-1 | 1898/99 |
| 16 January 1899 | Beats, Billy | West Bromwich Albion (a) | Birmingham Senior Cup | W | 7-0 | 1898/99 |
| 9 February 1901 | Wooldridge, Billy | New Brighton (H) | FA Cup | W | 5-1 | 1900/01 |
| 10 March 1902 | Pheasant, Ted | Newcastle United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-0 | 1901/02 |
| 26 November 1904 | Bevin, Fred | Middlesbrough (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-3 | 1904/05 |
| 16 April 1906 | Pedley, Jack | Notts County (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-1 | 1905/06 |
| 21 April 1906 | Wooldridge, Billy | Derby County (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-0 | 1905/06 |
| 22 September 1906 | Roberts, Jack | Bradford City (a) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-2 | 1906/07 |
| 10 November 1906 | Hedley, George | Burslem Port Vale (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 6-2 | 1906/07 |
| 28 December 1907 | Shelton, Jack | Grimsby Town (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-1 | 1907/08 |
| 7 November 1908 | Radford, Walter | Burnley (a) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-3 | 1908/09 |
| 28 December 1909 | Blunt, Bill (4) | Leicester Fosse (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-1 | 1909/10 |
| 15 January 1910 | Blunt, Bill (4) | Reading (H) | FA Cup | W | 5-0 | 1909/10 |
| 26 March 1910 | Blunt, Bill | Burnley (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-1 | 1909/10 |
| 17 September 1910 | Blunt, Bill (1p) | Bolton Wanderers (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-0 | 1910/11 |
| 4 November 1911 | Needham, Jack | Hull City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 8-0 | 1911/12 |
| 4 November 1911 | Halligan, Billy | Hull City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 8-0 | 1911/12 |
| 24 January 1912 | Halligan, Billy | Watford (H) | FA Cup | W | 10-0 | 1911/12 |
| 16 March 1912 | Halligan, Billy | Barnsley (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-0 | 1911/12 |
| 14 November 1914 | Curtis, Frank (4) | Leicester Fosse (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 7-0 | 1914/15 |
| 14 November 1914 | Needham, Jack | Leicester Fosse (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 7-0 | 1914/15 |
| 19 December 1914 | Richards, Dick | Stockport County (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-1 | 1914/15 |
| 1 November 1919 | Groves, Albert | Nottingham Forest (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-0 | 1919/20 |
| 26 February 1921 | Burrill, Frank | Stoke (H) | Football League (Division Two) | D | 3-3 | 1920/21 |
| 19 February 1923 | Burrill, Frank | Bradford City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-1 | 1922/23 |
| 2 April 1923 | Edmonds, George | Port Vale (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-0 | 1922/23 |
| 29 September 1923 | Fazackerley, Stan | Accrington Stanley (H) | Football League (Division Three (North)) | W | 5-1 | 1923/24 |
| 24 November 1923 | Lees, Harry | New Brighton (H) | Football League (Division Three (North)) | W | 5-1 | 1923/24 |
| 5 January 1924 | Phillipson, Tom | Ashington (a) | Football League (Division Three (North)) | W | 7-1 | 1923/24 |
| 26 January 1924 | Lees, Harry | Wrexham (H) | Football League (Division Three (North)) | W | 3-0 | 1923/24 |
| 16 January 1926 | Phillipson, Tom | Middlesbrough (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-1 | 1925/26 |
| 5 April 1926 | Phillipson, Tom | Stockport County (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-1 | 1925/26 |
| 26 April 1926 | Phillipson, Tom (4, 2p) | Barnsley (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 7-1 | 1925/26 |
| 6 November 1926 | Chadwick, Wilf | Barnsley (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 9-1 | 1926/27 |
| 6 November 1926 | Phillipson, Tom | Barnsley (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 9-1 | 1926/27 |
| 25 December 1926 | Phillipson, Tom (5) | Bradford City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 7-2 | 1926/27 |
| 5 February 1927 | Phillipson, Tom | Clapton Orient (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-0 | 1926/27 |
| 17 March 1928 | Weaver, Reg (1p) | Bristol City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-2 | 1927/28 |
| 3 September 1928 | Weaver, Reg | Millwall (a) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-0 | 1928/29 |
| 2 April 1929 | Green, Frank | Notts County (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-1 | 1928/29 |
| 28 September 1929 | Hartill, Billy | Preston North End (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-0 | 1929/30 |
| 12 October 1929 | Hartill, Billy (5) | Notts County (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-1 | 1929/30 |
| 26 April 1930 | Hartill, Billy | Bradford (PA) (H) | Football League (Division Two) | D | 4-4 | 1929/30 |
| 8 September 1930 | Hartill, Billy | Stoke City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-1 | 1930/31 |
| 1 November 1930 | Hartill, Billy | Bury (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 7-0 | 1930/31 |
| 22 November 1930 | Hartill, Billy | Bristol City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-0 | 1930/31 |
| 10 January 1931 | Phillips, Cuthbert | Wrexham (H) | FA Cup | W | 9-1 | 1930/31 |
| 10 January 1931 | Hartill, Billy (4) | Wrexham (H) | FA Cup | W | 9-1 | 1930/31 |
| 7 November 1931 | Hartill, Billy | Millwall (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-0 | 1931/32 |
| 21 November 1931 | Hartill, Billy | Bristol City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-2 | 1931/32 |
| 13 February 1932 | Hartill, Billy | Southampton (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-1 | 1931/32 |
| 9 April 1932 | Hartill, Billy | Oldham Athletic (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 7-1 | 1931/32 |
| 3 December 1932 | Hartill, Billy | Blackburn Rovers (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-3 | 1932/33 |
| 10 December 1932 | Hartill, Billy | Derby County (a) | Football League (Division One) | D | 4-4 | 1932/33 |
| 4 February 1933 | Hartill, Billy (4) | Huddersfield Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-4 | 1932/33 |
| 23 September 1933 | Hetherington, Jack | Huddersfield Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-2 | 1933/34 |
| 23 December 1933 | Phillips, Cuthbert | Manchester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 8-0 | 1933/34 |
| 3 September 1934 | Hartill, Billy (5) | Aston Villa (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-2 | 1934/35 |
| 25 December 1934 | Phillips, Cuthbert | Derby County (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-0 | 1934/35 |
| 19 January 1935 | Hartill, Billy (1p) | Tottenham Hotspur (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-2 | 1934/35 |
| 20 April 1936 | Jones, Bryn | Preston North End (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-2 | 1935/36 |
| 13 February 1937 | Clayton, George (4) | Everton (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-3 | 1936/37 |
| 3 April 1937 | Clayton, George (1p) | Grimsby Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-2 | 1936/37 |
| 28 August 1937 | Clayton, George | Manchester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-1 | 1937/38 |
| 8 January 1938 | Westcott, Dennis | Swansea Town (a) | FA Cup | W | 4-0 | 1937/38 |
| 15 April 1938 | Dorsett, Dickie (4) | Leicester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 10-1 | 1937/38 |
| 15 April 1938 | Westcott, Dennis (4) | Leicester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 10-1 | 1937/38 |
| 26 November 1938 | Westcott, Dennis | Chelsea (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-2 | 1938/39 |
| 27 December 1938 | Westcott, Dennis | Grimsby Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-0 | 1938/39 |
| 14 January 1939 | Westcott, Dennis | Brentford (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-2 | 1938/39 |
| 22 February 1939 | Dorsett, Dickie (4) | Everton (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-0 | 1938/39 |
| 25 March 1939 | Westcott, Dennis (4) | Grimsby Town (N) | FA Cup | W | 5-0 | 1938/39 |
| 28 October 1939 | Westcott, Dennis (4) | Northampton Town (H) | War Competition | W | 7-2 | 1939/40 |
| 2 December 1939 | Westcott, Dennis | Leicester City (H) | War Competition | W | 5-0 | 1939/40 |
| 9 December 1939 | Westcott, Dennis | Birmingham (H) | War Competition | W | 6-2 | 1939/40 |
| 23 December 1939 | Dorsett, Dickie (4) | Walsall (a) | War Competition | W | 5-3 | 1939/40 |
| 9 March 1940 | McMahon, Douglas | Leicester City (H) | War Competition | W | 5-1 | 1939/40 |
| 6 April 1940 | Westcott, Dennis | Luton Town (H) | War Competition | W | 6-1 | 1939/40 |
| 27 April 1940 | Dorsett, Dickie | Wrexham (H) | War Competition | W | 3-0 | 1939/40 |
| 13 May 1940 | Taylor, W (4) | West Bromwich Albion (H) | War Competition | W | 5-4 | 1939/40 |
| 13 December 1941 | Westcott, Dennis (6) | Nottingham Forest (H) | War Competition | W | 7-0 | 1941/42 |
| 7 March 1942 | Broome, Frank | Everton (H) | War Competition | W | 11-1 | 1941/42 |
| 7 March 1942 | Rowley, Jack (5) | Everton (H) | War Competition | W | 11-1 | 1941/42 |
| 11 April 1942 | Westcott, Dennis (1p) | Manchester United (a) | War Competition | L | 4-5 | 1941/42 |
| 21 November 1942 | Rowley, Jack (8) | Derby County (H) | War Competition | W | 8-1 | 1942/43 |
| 9 January 1943 | Westcott, Dennis | Wrexham (H) | War Competition | W | 4-0 | 1942/43 |
| 23 January 1943 | Wright, Billy | Stoke City (H) | War Competition | D | 4-4 | 1942/43 |
| 13 February 1943 | Wright, Billy | Crewe Alexandra (H) | War Competition | W | 6-1 | 1942/43 |
| 20 January 1945 | Jinks, Jimmy | Chester (H) | War Competition | W | 6-1 | 1944/45 |
| 17 February 1945 | Acquaroff, Jack | Wrexham (H) | War Competition | W | 4-1 | 1944/45 |
| 20 October 1945 | Buchanan, Cameron | Southampton (a) | War Competition | W | 4-2 | 1945/46 |
| 9 January 1946 | Galley, Tom (4) | Lovells Athletic (H) | FA Cup | W | 8-1 | 1945/46 |
| 16 February 1946 | Chatham, Ray | Portsmouth (H) | War Competition | W | 4-0 | 1945/46 |
| 23 February 1946 | Wright, Billy | Nottingham Forest (H) | War Competition | W | 4-0 | 1945/46 |
| 16 March 1946 | Westcott, Dennis | Newport County (H) | War Competition | W | 5-2 | 1945/46 |
| 20 April 1946 | Westcott, Dennis | Birmingham (H) | War Competition | D | 3-3 | 1945/46 |
| 31 August 1946 | Pye, Jesse | Arsenal (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-1 | 1946/47 |
| 7 December 1946 | Westcott, Dennis (4) | Liverpool (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1946/47 |
| 14 December 1946 | Westcott, Dennis (4) | Bolton Wanderers (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-0 | 1946/47 |
| 27 August 1947 | Pye, Jesse | Grimsby Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 8-1 | 1947/48 |
| 1 January 1948 | Westcott, Dennis | Middlesbrough (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-2 | 1947/48 |
| 2 October 1948 | Pye, Jesse | Huddersfield Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-1 | 1948/49 |
| 12 March 1949 | Wilshaw, Dennis | Newcastle United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-0 | 1948/49 |
| 24 September 1949 | Pye, Jesse | Huddersfield Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-1 | 1949/50 |
| 2 September 1950 | Swinbourne, Roy | Bolton Wanderers (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-1 | 1950/51 |
| 2 December 1950 | Hancocks, Johnny | West Bromwich Albion (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-1 | 1950/51 |
| 29 September 1951 | Dunn, Jimmy | Huddersfield Town (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-1 | 1951/52 |
| 13 October 1951 | Pye, Jesse | Bolton Wanderers (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1951/52 |
| 29 December 1951 | Whitfield, Ken | Blackpool (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-0 | 1951/52 |
| 4 October 1952 | Swinbourne, Roy | Manchester United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-2 | 1952/53 |
| 8 November 1952 | Swinbourne, Roy | Manchester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-3 | 1952/53 |
| 12 September 1953 | Swinbourne, Roy | Portsmouth (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-3 | 1953/54 |
| 26 September 1953 | Hancocks, Johnny | Chelsea (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 8-1 | 1953/54 |
| 6 February 1954 | Swinbourne, Roy | Blackpool (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-1 | 1953/54 |
| 12 February 1955 | Hancocks, Johnny | Huddersfield Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-4 | 1954/55 |
| 19 February 1955 | Wilshaw, Dennis | Charlton Athletic (H) | FA Cup | W | 4-1 | 1954/55 |
| 16 April 1955 | Hancocks, Johnny | Arsenal (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-1 | 1954/55 |
| 27 August 1955 | Swinbourne, Roy (4) | Manchester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-2 | 1955/56 |
| 3 September 1955 | Hancocks, Johnny | Cardiff City (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 9-1 | 1955/56 |
| 3 September 1955 | Swinbourne, Roy | Cardiff City (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 9-1 | 1955/56 |
| 10 September 1955 | Swinbourne, Roy | Huddersfield Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-0 | 1955/56 |
| 2 May 1956 | Booth, Colin | Sheffield United (a) | Football League (Division One) | D | 3-3 | 1955/56 |
| 18 August 1956 | Murray, Jimmy (4) | Manchester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1956/57 |
| 10 November 1956 | Booth, Colin (4) | Arsenal (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-2 | 1956/57 |
| 24 November 1956 | Hooper, Harry | Preston North End (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-0 | 1956/57 |
| 22 December 1956 | Wilshaw, Dennis | Blackpool (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-1 | 1956/57 |
| 15 February 1958 | Murray, Jimmy | Darlington (H) | FA Cup | W | 6-1 | 1957/58 |
| 22 February 1958 | Murray, Jimmy | Birmingham City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1957/58 |
| 15 March 1958 | Murray, Jimmy | Nottingham Forest (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-1 | 1957/58 |
| 23 August 1958 | Mason, Bobby | Nottingham Forest (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1958/59 |
| 26 December 1958 | Broadbent, Peter | Portsmouth (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-3 | 1958/59 |
| 27 December 1958 | Deeley, Norman | Portsmouth (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-0 | 1958/59 |
| 27 December 1958 | Booth, Colin | Portsmouth (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-0 | 1958/59 |
| 21 March 1959 | Lill, Micky | West Bromwich Albion (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1958/59 |
| 16 September 1959 | Deeley, Norman (4, 1p) | Fulham (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 9-0 | 1959/60 |
| 2 April 1960 | Mannion, Gerry | Leeds United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-0 | 1959/60 |
| 3 December 1960 | Farmer, Ted | Arsenal (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-3 | 1960/61 |
| 31 December 1960 | Murray, Jimmy | Chelsea (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-1 | 1960/61 |
| 18 March 1961 | Farmer, Ted (4) | Birmingham City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1960/61 |
| 18 August 1962 | Farmer, Ted (4) | Manchester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 8-1 | 1962/63 |
| 8 December 1962 | Hinton, Alan | Fulham (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-0 | 1962/63 |
| 16 March 1963 | Wharton, Terry | West Bromwich Albion (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 7-0 | 1962/63 |
| 24 April 1964 | Crawford, Ray | Bolton Wanderers (a) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-0 | 1963/64 |
| 1 March 1965 | McIlmoyle, Hugh | Aston Villa (N) | FA Cup | W | 3-1 | 1964/65 |
| 20 April 1965 | Woodruff, Bobby | Sunderland (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-0 | 1964/65 |
| 28 August 1965 | Knowles, Peter | Carlisle United (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 3-0 | 1965/66 |
| 11 September 1965 | Knowles, Peter | Derby County (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-0 | 1965/66 |
| 21 September 1966 | Wharton, Terry (2p) | Cardiff City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 7-1 | 1966/67 |
| 29 October 1966 | Hunt, Ernie | Northampton Town (a) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-0 | 1966/67 |
| 25 March 1967 | Dougan, Derek | Hull City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-0 | 1966/67 |
| 6 April 1968 | Dougan, Derek | Nottingham Forest (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 6-1 | 1967/68 |
| 4 May 1968 | Wignall, Frank | Chelsea (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-0 | 1967/68 |
| 3 October 1970 | Gould, Bobby | Manchester United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-2 | 1970/71 |
| 3 April 1971 | Curran, Hugh | Nottingham Forest (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-0 | 1970/71 |
| 25 September 1971 | Dougan, Derek | Nottingham Forest (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-2 | 1971/72 |
| 29 September 1971 | Dougan, Derek | Academica Coimbra (a) | UEFA Cup | W | 4-1 | 1971/72 |
| 30 September 1972 | Richards, John | Stoke City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-3 | 1972/73 |
| 3 March 1973 | Dougan, Derek | Manchester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-1 | 1972/73 |
| 14 April 1973 | Richards, John | Everton (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-2 | 1972/73 |
| 24 August 1974 | Hibbitt, Kenny (4, 1p) | Newcastle United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 4-2 | 1974/75 |
| 31 March 1975 | Hibbitt, Kenny (1p) | Luton Town (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-2 | 1974/75 |
| 14 February 1976 | Richards, John | Charlton Athletic (H) | FA Cup | W | 3-0 | 1975/76 |
| 10 April 1976 | Richards, John | Newcastle United (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 5-0 | 1975/76 |
| 23 October 1976 | Sunderland, Alan | Carlisle United (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-0 | 1976/77 |
| 27 November 1976 | Richards, John (1p) | Orient (a) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-2 | 1976/77 |
| 1 October 1977 | Richards, John | Leicester City (H) | Football League (Division One) | W | 3-0 | 1977/78 |
| 9 May 1987 | Bull, Steve | Hartlepool United (H) | Football League (Division Four) | W | 4-1 | 1986/87 |
| 14 November 1987 | Bull, Steve | Cheltenham Town (H) | FA Cup | W | 5-1 | 1987/88 |
| 19 January 1988 | Bull, Steve | Brentford (H) | Associate Members Cup | W | 4-0 | 1987/88 |
| 13 February 1988 | Bull, Steve | Exeter City (a) | Football League (Division Four) | W | 4-2 | 1987/88 |
| 26 March 1988 | Bull, Steve | Darlington (H) | Football League (Division Four) | W | 5-3 | 1987/88 |
| 26 November 1988 | Bull, Steve (4) | Preston North End (H) | Football League (Division Three) | W | 6-0 | 1988/89 |
| 13 December 1988 | Bull, Steve (4) | Port Vale (H) | Associate Members Cup | W | 5-1 | 1988/89 |
| 17 December 1988 | Bull, Steve | Mansfield Town (H) | Football League (Division Three) | W | 6-2 | 1988/89 |
| 24 January 1989 | Bull, Steve | Bristol City (H) | Associate Members Cup | W | 3-0 | 1988/89 |
| 11 February 1989 | Bull, Steve | Fulham (H) | Football League (Division Three) | W | 5-2 | 1988/89 |
| 18 March 1989 | Bull, Steve | Bury (H) | Football League (Division Three) | W | 4-0 | 1988/89 |
| 1 January 1990 | Bull, Steve (4) | Newcastle United (a) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-1 | 1989/90 |
| 10 April 1990 | Bull, Steve | Leicester City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 5-0 | 1989/90 |
| 6 October 1990 | Bull, Steve | Bristol City (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 4-0 | 1990/91 |
| 16 March 1991 | Bull, Steve | Oxford United (H) | Football League (Division Two) | D | 3-3 | 1990/91 |
| 31 March 1992 | Mutch, Andy | Newcastle United (H) | Football League (Division Two) | W | 6-1 | 1991/92 |
| 27 September 1992 | Roberts, Darren | Birmingham City (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 4-0 | 1992/93 |
| 6 November 1993 | Bull, Steve | Derby County (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 4-0 | 1993/94 |
| 1 November 1994 | Kelly, David | Bristol City (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 5-1 | 1994/95 |
| 25 February 1995 | de Wolf, John | Port Vale (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 4-2 | 1994/95 |
| 17 August 1996 | Bull, Steve | Grimsby Town (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 3-1 | 1996/97 |
| 15 September 1996 | Roberts, Iwan | West Bromwich Albion (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 4-2 | 1996/97 |
| 10 January 1998 | Freedman, Dougie | Norwich City (H) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 5-0 | 1997/98 |
| 18 August 1998 | Bull, Steve | Barnet (H) | League Cup | W | 5-0 | 1998/99 |
| 7 November 1998 | Connolly, David (4) | Bristol City (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 6-1 | 1998/99 |
| 6 November 1999 | Akinbiyi, Adi | Grimsby Town (H) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 3-0 | 1999/00 |
| 13 October 2001 | Proudlock, Adam | Bradford City (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 3-0 | 2001/02 |
| 27 November 2001 | Sturridge, Dean | Barnsley (H) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 4-1 | 2001/02 |
| 29 October 2002 | Blake, Nathan | Gillingham (a) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 4-0 | 2002/03 |
| 1 March 2003 | Miller, Kenny (1p) | Crystal Palace (H) | Football League (New First Division) | W | 4-0 | 2002/03 |
| 30 August 2005 | Cort, Carl | Queens Park Rangers (H) | Football League (Championship) | W | 3-1 | 2005/06 |
| 20 September 2008 | Iwelumo, Chris (1p) | Preston North End (a) | Football League (Championship) | W | 3-1 | 2008/09 |
| 3 February 2009 | Ebanks-Blake, Sylvan | Norwich City (H) | Football League (Championship) | D | 3-3 | 2008/09 |
| 18 April 2014 | Dicko, Nouho | Rotherham U (H) | Football League (Championship) | W | 6-4 | 2013/14 |
| 19 January 2019 | Jota, Diogo | Leicester City (H) | Premier League | W | 4-3 | 2018/19 |
| 12 December 2019 | Jota, Diogo | Besiktas (H) | Europa League | W | 4-0 | 2019/20 |
| 20 February 2020 | Jota, Diogo | Espanyol (H) | Europa League | W | 4-0 | 2019/20 |
| 4 February 2024 | Cunha, Matheus | Chelsea (a) | Premier League | W | 4-2 | 2023/24 |
