| First Team Matches | Second Team Matches | Youth Team Matches | League Debuts | Associated with both clubs | Transfers |
| 59 | Brockstopp, A | Molineux | 3 September 1894 | L 0-3 | |
| 72 | Tennant, W | Bramall Lane | 8 February 1896 | L 1-2 | |
| 142 | Lloyd, A | Molineux | 23 December 1905 | D 1-1 | |
| 366 | Farrow, G | Molineux | 1 October 1932 | W 5-1 | |
| 374 | Wildsmith, T | Bramall Lane | 11 February 1933 | D 0-0 | |
| 459 | Springthorpe, T | Molineux | 13 March 1948 | D 1-1 | |
| 467 | Sims, N | Bramall Lane | 18 April 1949 | D 1-1 | |
| 589 | Kelly, J | Bramall Lane | 5 February 1974 | L 0-1 | |
| 593 | Williams, N | Molineux | 24 September 1974 | D 1-1 | |
| 598 | Patching, M | Molineux | 11 October 1975 | W 5-1 | |
| 650 | Flowers, T | Molineux | 25 August 1984 | D 2-2 | |
| 651 | Ainscow, A | Molineux | 25 August 1984 | D 2-2 | |
| 652 | Langley, T | Molineux | 25 August 1984 | D 2-2 | 1g |
| 653 | Evans, A | Molineux | 25 August 1984 | D 2-2 | |
| 654 | Ryan, D | Molineux | 25 August 1984 | D 2-2 | Sub |
| 662 | Coady, M | Bramall Lane | 26 January 1985 | D 2-2 | |
| 785 | Paatelainen, M | Molineux | 16 September 1997 | D 0-0 | |
| 802 | Green, R | Molineux | 10 November 1998 | W 2-1 | |
| 843 | Clyde, M | Molineux | 5 October 2002 | L 1-3 | |
| 1041 | Marcel | Bramall Lane | 14 September 2020 | W 2-0 | |
| 1042 | Vintinha | Bramall Lane | 14 September 2020 | W 2-0 | Sub |
