Monday 30 September 1889 at Anfield (Att 4,000)

Everton (1) 1 (Chadwick 5): Smalley, Hannah, Doyle, Parry, Holt, Farmer, Latta, Kirkwood, Geary, Chadwick, Milward.
Wolves (0) 1 (Wykes*): Rose, Knight, C Mason, Fletcher, Allen, Lowder, Cooper, Worrall, Wykes, Wood, Booth.

Position: 4th.