| A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z |
| From | Cost | Date | To | Cost | Date | ||
| Picken | A H | Wellington Town | Fee Unknown | 12 May 1922 | Bolton Wanderers | Fee Unknown | 1925 |
| Pickerall | J | Dudley Road Swifts | Fee Unknown | 2 October 1889 | Dudley Town | Fee Unknown | April 1890 |
| Pickstoff | S | Rochdale | Guest | 1944-45 | NA | ||
| Piearce | S | Juniors | NA | 1 August 1995 | Hednesford Town | Loan | 1995 |
| Doncaster Rovers | Loan | 15 July 1996 | |||||
| Pierce | G | Huddersfield Town | £40,000 | 1 August 1973 | Barnsley | £30,000 | 27 July 1979 |
| Pilsbury | C | Wolverhampton Wesleyans | Fee Unknown | 29 April 1903 | Wellington Town | Fee Unknown | 18 May 1904 |
| Pincott | F C | Bristol Victoria | Fee Unknown | 3 November 1931 | Bournemouth & BA | Fee Unknown | 28 May 1934 |
| Platt | F | Unknown | 10 May 1898 | 1900 | |||
| Pleasant | J | Amateur | NP | 26 April 1942 | Released | 1944 | |
| Plunkett | S E | Norwich City | Fee Unknown | 29 April 1939 | Norwich City | Fee Unknown | 12 May 1946 |
| Podence | D C | Olympiacos [Gre] | £17,640,000 | 30 January 2020 | Olympiacos [Gre] | Loan | 4 September 2023 |
| Pollet | L | Lens [Fra] | Loan | 7 September 1999 | Walsall | Loan | 14 November 2002 |
| Lens [Fra] | £350,000 | 21 October 1999 | US Dunkerque [Fra] | Released | 2 June 2003 | ||
| Pond | A | Exeter City | Fee Unknown | 1 September 2022 | Stockport County | Loan | 31 August 2023 |
| Poole | A J | Northampton Town | Free | 18 August 1982 | Released | 1 March 1982 | |
| Poole | R | Juniors | NA | 3 January 1957 | Rotherham United | Fee Unknown | 5 July 1958 |
| Pope | F H | Cradley Heath | Fee Unknown | 4 April 1900 | Stourbridge | Fee Unknown | 29 September 2002 |
| Stourbridge | Fee Unknown | 4 May 1905 | Notts County | Fee Unknown | 21 April 1906 | ||
| Poppitt | J | Wellington Town | Fee Unknown | 2 May 1900 | 1902 | ||
| Postma | S | Aston Villa | Loan | 19 August 2005 | ADO Den Haag [Hol] | Released | 8 May 2006 |
| Aston Villa | Free | 6 January 2006 | |||||
| Pote | Valencia [Spa] | Free | 18 July 2017 | Famalicao [Por] | £1,170,000 | 2 July 2019 | |
| Potter | D M | Liverpool | Loan | 17 August 2006 | Sheffield Wednesday | Loan | 15 January 2009 |
| Liverpool | £250,000 | 18 January 2007 | Sheffield Wednesday | £360,000 | 10 July 2009 | ||
| Potts | A A | Manchester City | Fee Unknown | 8 June 1920 | Walsall | Fee Unknown | 26 October 1922 |
| Povey | V R | Juniors | NA | 26 July 1961 | Notts County | Fee Unknown | 23 August 1963 |
| Powell | B I | Juniors | NA | 4 January 1972 | Coventry City | £75,000 | 3 September 1975 |
| Unattached | NA | 29 November 1986 | Retired | ||||
| Preece | J C | Sunbeam Motor Works | Fee Unknown | 5 May 1932 | Willenhall Town | Fee Unknown | 1934 |
| Preece | R | Juniors | NP | 1983 | Wrexham | Released | 4 April 1985 |
| Preston | H | Ironbridge | Fee Unknown | 4 May 1901 | Kidderminster Harriers | Fee Unknown | 8 May 1905 |
| Price | A B R | Moor Green | Fee Unknown | 5 April 1907 | Acocks Green | Fee Unknown | 1 August 1907 |
| Price | F | Dudley | Fee Unknown | 3 May 1912 | Port Vale | Fee Unknown | 29 August 1921 |
| Price | FT | Southampton | Fee Unknown | 9 May 1925 | Chesterfield | Fee Unknown | 25 June 1927 |
| Price | J A | Juniors | NA | 1 July 2013 | Yeovil Town | Loan | 1 September 2014 |
| Leyton Orient | Loan | 7 October 2014 | |||||
| C Rapids [USA] | Fee Unknown | 12 January 2018 | |||||
| Price | J A | Wellington Town | Fee Unknown | 12 November 1920 | Unknown | 1924 | |
| Prince | H | Juniors | NA | 26 July 1943 | Port Vale | Fee Unknown | 1944 |
| Pringle | J | Amateur | NP | 10 March 1942 | Released | 1942 | |
| Pritchard | R T | Juniors | NA | 18 September 1942 | Mansfield Town | Guest | 1942-43 |
| Swindon Town | Guest | 1945-46 | |||||
| Aston Villa | £6,500 | 10 February 1955 | |||||
| Pritchard | T F | Newport County | Fee Unknown | 20 September 1927 | Charlton Athletic | Fee Unknown | 27 May 1929 |
| Pritchett | K B | Juniors | NA | 24 April 1972 | Doncaster Rovers | Fee Unknown | 25 July 1973 |
| Proudlock | A D | Juniors | NA | 15 July 1999 | Clyde [Sco] | Loan | 1 August 2000 |
| Nottingham Forest | Loan | 20 March 2002 | |||||
| Tranmere Rovers | Loan | 25 October 2002 | |||||
| Sheffield Wednesday | Loan | 13 December 2002 | |||||
| Sheffield Wednesday | £150,000 | 5 September 2003 | |||||
| Pugh | H | 1918 | 1919 | ||||
| Pugh | S J | Juniors | NA | 24 December 1982 | Torquay United | Free | 1 October 1983 |
| Punter | B | Juniors | NA | 1 September 1953 | Kidderminster Harriers | Fee Unknown | 14 July 1954 |
| Purdie | J | Arsenal | Free Agent | 2 August 1985 | Cambridge United | Loan | 24 October 1987 |
| Oxford United | Fee Unknown | 4 July 1988 | |||||
| Pye | J | Notts County | Combined fee £10,000 | 11 May 1946 | Luton Town | Five Figures | 7 July 1952 |
|
