| 1880s | 1890s | 1900s | 1910s | 1920s | 1930s | 1940s | 1950s | 1960s | 1970s | 1980s | 1990s | 2000s | 2010s | 2020s |
| Date | Player | Opponents | V | Results | Season | |||
| 511 | 5 March 1960 | Mannion G | Manchester United | (a) | W | 2-0 | 1959/60 | |
| 512 | 5 March 1960 | Stobart B | Manchester United | (a) | W | 2-0 | 1959/60 | |
| 513 | 24 September 1960 | Farmer J | Manchester United | (a) | W | 3-1 | 2gs | 1960/61 |
| 514 | 4 February 1961 | Cocker L | Blackburn Rovers | (a) | L | 1-2 | 1960/61 | |
| 515 | 11 February 1961 | Brodie C | Manchester United | (H) | W | 2-1 | 1960/61 | |
| 516 | 26 August 1961 | Harris J | West Ham United | (H) | W | 3-2 | 1961/62 | |
| 517 | 26 August 1960 | Hinton A | West Ham United | (H) | W | 3-2 | 1961/62 | |
| 518 | 23 September 1961 | Lazarus M | Cardiff City | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1961/62 | |
| 519 | 11 November 1961 | Wharton T | Ipswich Town | (H) | W | 2-0 | 1g | 1961/62 |
| 520 | 3 February 1962 | Davies F | Tottenham Hotspur | (H) | W | 3-1 | 1961/62 | |
| 521 | 3 February 1962 | Thomson R | Tottenham Hotspur | (H) | W | 3-1 | 1961/62 | |
| 522 | 3 February 1962 | Crowe C | Tottenham Hotspur | (H) | W | 3-1 | 1g | 1961/62 |
| 523 | 3 February 1962 | McParland P | Tottenham Hotspur | (H) | W | 3-1 | 1g | 1961/62 |
| 524 | 14 April 1962 | Goodwin F | Arsenal | (a) | L | 1-3 | 1961/62 | |
| 525 | 23 April 1962 | Woodfield D | Chelsea | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1961/62 | |
| 526 | 8 December 1962 | Galley J | Fulham | (a) | W | 5-0 | 1g | 1962/63 |
| 527 | 16 December 1963 | Crawford R | Liverpool | (a) | L | 0-6 | 1963/64 | |
| 528 | 14 October 1963 | Knowles P | Leicester City | (a) | W | 1-0 | 1963/64 | |
| 529 | 30 November 1963 | Barron J | Everton | (H) | D | 0-0 | 1963/64 | |
| 530 | 1 February 1964 | le Flem R | Blackpool | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1963/64 | |
| 531 | 7 March 1964 | Woodruff R | Birmingham City | (H) | W | 5-1 | 1963/64 | |
| 532 | 21 March 1964 | Melia J | Burnley | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1963/64 | |
| 533 | 22 August 1964 | Ford C | Chelsea | (H) | L | 0-3 | 1964/65 | |
| 534 | 5 September 1964 | Thompson D | Arsenal | (H) | L | 0-1 | 1964/65 | |
| 535 | 30 September 1964 | Buckley P | Birmingham City | (H) | L | 0-2 | 1964/65 | |
| 536 | 10 October 1964 | Hawkins G | West Bromwich Albion | (a) | L | 1-5 | 1964/65 | |
| 537 | 24 October 1964 | McIlmoyle H | Fulham | (a) | L | 0-2 | 1964/65 | |
| 538 | 31 October 1964 | Miller G | Nottingham Forest | (H) | L | 1-2 | 1964/65 | |
| 539 | 13 December 1964 | Knighton K | Liverpool | (a) | L | 1-2 | 1964/65 | |
| 540 | 19 December 1964 | Kemp F | Leeds United | (H) | L | 0-1 | 1964/65 | |
| 541 | 26 December 1964 | Wagstaffe D | Aston Villa | (a) | L | 0-1 | 1964/65 | |
| 542 | 2 January 1965 | MacLaren D | Arsenal | (a) | L | 1-4 | 1964/65 | |
| 543 | 30 March 1965 | Wilson.J | Fulham | (H) | D | 0-0 | 1964/65 | |
| 544 | 25 September 1965 | Holsgrove J | Bury | (H) | W | 3-0 | 1965/66 | |
| 545 | 25 September 1965 | Hunt R | Bury | (H) | W | 3-0 | 1965/66 | |
| 546 | 18 December 1965 | Wilson L | Middlesbrough | (a) | L | 1-3 | 1965/66 | |
| 547 | 12 March 1966 | Bailey M | Southampton | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1965/66 | |
| 548 | 20 August 1966 | Farrington J | Birmingham City | (H) | L | 1-2 | 1966/67 | |
| 549 | 7 September 1966 | Burnside D | Crystal Palace | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1g | 1966/67 |
| 550 | 17 September 1966 | Wallace I | Blackburn Rovers | (H) | W | 4-0 | Sub | 1966/67 |
| 551 | 8 October 1966 | Hatton R | Portsmouth | (H) | W | 3-1 | 1g | 1966/67 |
| 552 | 19 November 1966 | Parkes P | Preston North End | (H) | W | 3-2 | 1966/67 | |
| 553 | 31 December 1966 | Taylor G | Ipswich Town | (H) | D | 0-0 | 1966/67 | |
| 554 | 18 March 1967 | Dougan D | Plymouth Argyle | (a) | W | 1-0 | 1966/67 | |
| 555 | 16 September 1967 | Evans A | West Ham United | (a) | W | 2-1 | 1967/68 | |
| 556 | 23 October 1967 | Williams E | Arsenal | (H) | W | 3-2 | 1967/68 | |
| 557 | 30 December 1967 | Ross S | Manchester United | (H) | L | 2-3 | 1967/68 | |
| 558 | 6 January 1968 | Munro F | Everton | (H) | L | 1-3 | 1967/68 | |
| 559 | 13 January 1968 | Kenning M | Leicester City | (a) | L | 1-3 | 1g | 1967/68 |
| 560 | 24 February 1968 | Parkin D | Newcastle United | (a) | L | 0-2 | 1967/68 | |
| 561 | 9 March 1968 | Wignall F | Sunderland | (H) | W | 2-1 | 1967/68 | |
| 562 | 29 April 1968 | McAlle J | Chelsea | (a) | L | 0-1 | 1967/68 | |
| 563 | 31 August 1968 | Clarke D | Stoke City | (H) | D | 1-1 | Sub | 1968/69 |
| 564 | 14 September 1968 | Boswell A | Sunderland | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1968/69 | |
| 565 | 1 February 1969 | Curran H | Burnley | (H) | D | 1-1 | 1968/69 | |
| 566 | 22 March 1969 | Galvin D | Stoke City | (a) | L | 1-3 | 1968/69 | |
| 567 | 24 March 1969 | Seal J | West Ham United | (a) | L | 1-3 | 1968/69 | |
| 568 | 8 April 1969 | Lutton R | Manchester City | (H) | W | 3-1 | 1968/69 | |
| 569 | 12 April 1969 | Hibbitt K | West Bromwich Albion | (H) | L | 0-1 | Sub | 1968/69 |
| 570 | 19 April 1969 | McVeigh J | Sunderland | (a) | L | 0-2 | 1968/69 | |
| 571 | 19 April 1969 | Walker P | Sunderland | (a) | L | 0-2 | Sub | 1968/69 |
| 572 | 9 August 1969 | McCalliog J | Stoke City | (H) | W | 3-1 | 1969/70 | |
| 573 | 27 September 1969 | O’Grady M | Newcastle United | (a) | D | 1-1 | 1969/70 | |
| 574 | 8 October 1969 | Shaw B | Sheffield Wednesday | (H) | D | 2-2 | 1969/70 |
